Amid all the uproar surrounding the Home Affordable Modification Program (HAMP), it was revealed today that Bank of America completed just 98 permanent loan modifications.
While that figure is certain to rise thanks to the bank’s 156,864 active trial modifications currently underway, the numbers are seriously weak compared to other major loan servicers.
GMAC Mortgage managed to make 7,111 loan modifications permanent, while Chase has 4,302 on the books, followed by Ocwen with 4,252, Aurora Loan Services with 3,622, and Wells Fargo with 3,537.
In recent weeks, both Bank of America and Chase have complained about the government-sponsored loan modification program, saying it has been difficult to get all the required paperwork from borrowers.
But all excuses aside, Bank of America is well behind its peers, and as the top mortgage lender and servicer in the nation, it seems pretty inexcusable.
In total, only 31,382 loan modifications have been made permanent, while 697,026 are in trial mode; yep, just over four percent have gone the distance so far.
Per HAMP rules, to receive a permanent modification borrowers must make at least three trial payments, provide documents that include proof of income and hardship verification, and have their credit re-underwritten.
To facilitate the process, the Obama Administration recently extended the trial period for modifications started on or before September 1 so borrowers have more time to submit required information.
California leads the nation in total loan modifications (trial+permanent) with 148,350, followed by Florida with 90,575 and Illinois with 37,552.
Oh, and more than a quarter of trial loan modifications executed under HAMP are already delinquent…
(photo: leoreynolds)
Wells Fargo has reportedly modified $15.7 billion in nasty pay-option arms through the first three quarters of the year, according to Bloomberg.
The negative amortization loans, which were acquired via its merger with Wachovia, have carried a serious delinquency rate triple that of standard loans, making them a high priority for the San Francisco-based bank.
The company has gone above and beyond offering simple repayment plans and interest rate cuts by agreeing to reduce principal balances, a necessity because most option arms are underwater thanks to continuing home price depreciation.
Wells Fargo has forgiven principal by an average of 15 percent, or $46,000, on 43,500 option arms modified this year through September.
In certain situations, principal was reduced by as much as 30 percent, though the ceiling is typically capped at 20 percent.
In total, about $2 billion in pay-option loan balances have been reduced, resulting in $13.7 billion in modified mortgages that no longer qualify as option arms.
Wells Fargo is also employing the standard loss mitigation efforts, such as interest-rate reductions, term extensions, and the use of interest-only loans.
Pay option arms were very popular during the housing boom because homeowners could make payments below the actual interest rate tied to the loan, relying on the promise of home price appreciation to mask any associated risk.
But when home prices turned, borrowers who made the ultra-low payments quickly found that their loan balances exceeded the value of their homes.
(photo: batega)
Foreclosure filings decreased for the fourth consecutive month in November, according to foreclosure listing service RealtyTrac.
Foreclosure activity, which includes anything from a notice of default to a bank repossession, declined by eight percent compared to October, but was still 18 percent higher than November 2008.
“Loan modifications and other foreclosure prevention efforts, along with the recently extended and expanded homebuyer tax credit, are keeping a lid on the most visible symptoms of the nation’s ailing housing market — foreclosures and home value depreciation, said James J. Saccacio, chief executive officer of RealtyTrac.
“This is providing a welcome respite for the real estate industry, but a full recovery will only come when unemployment recedes to normal, healthy levels and when availability of credit reaches a more rational balance between the extremes of the past few years.”
Notices of default, the first step in the foreclosure process, were down eight percent compared to October, while scheduled foreclosure actions slipped 12 percent and bank repossessions remained flat.
Foreclosure activity decreased 33 percent in hard-hit Nevada, but the state continues to document the nation’s highest foreclosure rate, at one in every 119 households.
At the same time, the Las Vegas metro area dropped to fifth from first in terms of foreclosure filings, with just one in 102 housing units receiving a notice in November.
Merced, CA took the top spot, with one in every 83 housing units receiving a foreclosure filing in November, followed by Stockton, CA and Modesto, CA.
California, Florida, Illinois and Michigan accounted for 52 percent of the nation’s total foreclosure activity last month.
Mortgage rates climber higher this week after hitting record lows in the previous survey, according to mortgage financier Freddie Mac.
“Following an upbeat employment report, long-term bond yields rose slightly and fixed mortgage rates followed,” said Frank Nothaft, Freddie Mac vice president and chief economist, in a statement.
“The economy shed only 11,000 jobs in November, far fewer than the market consensus forecast, and the unemployment rate unexpectedly fell to 10 percent. In addition, revisions added 159,000 jobs to September and October.”
Good economic news tends to push interest rates higher, while the opposite is also true (how mortgage rates are determined).
The popular 30-year fixed-rate mortgage averaged 4.81 percent for the week ending December 10, up from 4.71 percent a week ago, but below the 5.47 percent average seen a year ago.
The 15-year fixed increased to 4.32 percent from 4.27 percent, but remains well below the 5.20 percent seen this time last year.
The five-year adjustable-rate mortgage climbed to 4.26 percent from 4.19 percent, while the one-year ARM slipped a single basis point to 4.24 point.
A year ago, the five-year averaged 5.82 percent and the one-year stood at 5.09 percent.
The mortgage rates above are good for conforming loan amounts at 80 percent loan-to-value; they don’t include pricing adjustments.
Jumbo loans continue to price a percentage point or more higher.
(photo: woinary)
Another sign of the times…
U.S. consumers seem to be more interested in paying their credit cards than making their monthly mortgage payments, according to a new survey from Cardbeat/Auriemma Consulting Group (ACG).
In previous years, consumers had always said the mortgage is the bill they would pay first, but now credit cards have grabbed the top spot.
“ACG believes that this change is driven by two market trends,” said Nancy Stahl, editor of Cardbeat. “First, credit has become tighter. Issuers have cut credit lines, and cardholders are aware that missed or late payments can trigger rate increases or account closure.”
Stahl noted that cash-strapped consumers view credit cards as their “lifeline” to manage everyday expenses, while adding that foreclosures have become commonplace.
“Intense media coverage of the housing crisis and of legislative efforts to assist homeowners who fall behind may be swaying borrowers toward the conclusion that it’s more important to be current on their credit card than on their mortgage.”
In a way it makes sense; consumers rely on credit cards for daily purchases, and they certainly don’t want to lose that capacity to spend, especially during the holidays.
At the same time, many seem to be giving up on the mortgage, either because they’re deeply underwater, unemployed, hopeless, or perhaps because they’re banking on government aid.
The data from the survey, conducted in October, is based on 430 credit card users.
Mortgage application volume increased 8.5 percent on a seasonally adjusted basis for the week ending December 4, according to the latest survey from the Mortgage Bankers Association.
On an unadjusted basis, the index was up 54 percent compared with one week earlier, though that was the holiday shortened Thanksgiving week.
The weekly gain was led by an 11.1 percent increase in refinance applications and a four percent increase in purchase activity, mainly via FHA loans.
But applications to purchase a home were still off 18.8 percent compared with the same period a year earlier, which doesn’t say a whole lot about the extension of the homebuyer tax credit.
The refinance share of mortgage activity increased to 74.4 percent of total applications from 72.1 percent a week earlier despite a rise in interest rates.
The popular 30-year fixed averaged 4.88 percent, up from 4.79 percent, while the 15-year fixed climbed to 4.33 percent from 4.27 percent.
Meanwhile, the one-year adjustable-rate mortgage bucked the rising trend, falling a single basis point to 6.55 percent.
The MBA’s weekly survey covers more than half of all retail, residential home loan applications, but does not factor out declined or multiple apps.
The Home Affordable Modification Program (HAMP) came under more pressure today after Chase revealed the process has been cumbersome and less successful than its own loss mitigation efforts.
Since the program launched earlier this year, Chase has offered 199,033 HAMP modifications, with just 16,131 approved for permanent mods and only 4,302 actually completed.
That compares to 160,826 Chase loan modifications offered, 72,888 approved for permanent mods, and 58,239 completing the process.
More than half of the borrowers who were offered HAMP trials by Chase between April and September have already made the required three payments, but failed to provide necessary paperwork to move forward.
“We first attempt to help struggling borrowers using the Home Affordable Mortgage Program. If they are not eligible for it, we use a range of other modification programs,” said Charlie Scharf, head of Retail Financial Services at Chase, part of JPMorgan Chase & Co.
“We continue to work very hard to convert customers from a trial modification to a permanent modification that lowers their monthly payment, but it has been a struggle,” he said.
Per HAMP rules, to receive a permanent modification borrowers must make at least three trial payments, provide documents that include proof of income and hardship verification, and have their credit re-underwritten.
Some believe borrowers aren’t providing the documents because they fudged the numbers, while others claim Chase and other banks are intentionally making the process difficult for homeowners because they don’t stand to benefit from the loan modifications.
Even so, a staggering 29 percent of borrowers who received trial loan mods failed to make the required payments, so you can’t simply blame the process.
To step up efforts, Chase has coordinated a program that calls customers up to 36 times, mails them 15 times, and makes at least two visits to their home, if necessary, to get the required documentation.
The national mortgage delinquency rate is expected to eventually decline late next year after a number of unprecedented year-over-year increases, according to credit bureau TransUnion.
The company believes the mortgage delinquency rate (loans 60 or more days past due) will drop to 6.39 percent by the end of 2010 from an expected 6.56 percent by the end of this year.
That’s just a three percent year-over-year change, which it’s nothing to get too excited about; but it’s certainly better than the 54 percent increase between 2006 and 2007, 53 percent increase between 2007 and 2008, and 43 percent increase between 2008 and 2009.
“We believe the nation will see a turnaround in mortgage delinquencies in the coming year,” said Ezra Becker, director of consulting and strategy in TransUnion’s financial services group. “Tied directly to anticipated unemployment rates and housing values, the decrease in delinquencies should be gradual. “This is a dramatic shift from the 43 to 54 percent year-over-year increases we have seen the last three years.
“We expect this change to be driven in part through the continued conservative approach lenders are taking to new loan underwriting, as many of the existing mortgages in the market work their way out of the system and off the books of lending institutions.”
Though the nation as a whole will see fewer mortgage delinquencies, a number of important states will see late payments rise throughout next year.
Hard-hit Florida is expected to see mortgage lates rise 17.34 percent year-over-year, pushing its delinquency rate to a national high 16.86 percent.
Arizona, California, New York, and Virginia are also expected to see year-over-year increases in delinquencies, so were not out of the woods yet.
Substantial double-digit declines in mortgage delinquencies are expected in North Dakota, Minnesota, and Oklahoma, where housing values are forecast to improve.
Too bad the epicenter of the mortgage crisis isn’t in North Dakota…
More than a quarter of trial loan modifications executed under the Making Home Affordable program are already delinquent, according to testimony from a Treasury official.
Assistant Treasury Secretary Herbert Allison told a congressional oversight panel that over 73 percent of borrowers with trial loan mods are current, which after seeing other re-default numbers, seems pretty good.
But that still leaves 27 percent delinquent, and that’s after only three months; trial modifications were originally intended to become permanent after 90 days of on-time payments.
However, last week the Treasury extended the trial period of loan mods to five months so borrowers would have more time to gather required paperwork, at least that’s the story.
Since the program got underway earlier this year, banks and loan servicer have carried out 650,000 trial loan modifications.
And 375,000 are scheduled to become permanent by year-end, assuming borrowers are able to provide necessary documents and prove the new loans are sustainable.
Later this month, Treasury is expected to announce just how many of the those trials made it to permanent status, a telling number with regard to the success of the program.
As part of the push to make loan mods permanent, participating loan servicers will also face possible monetary penalties and/or sanctions if they fail to meet performance obligations.
(photo: jontintinjordan)
A New Jersey woman facing foreclosure found herself locked out of her home after returning from a Thanksgiving trip, according to a report from an ABC affiliate in Philadelphia.
The 57-year old woman, Nina Morra, who had recently suffered a stroke back in January and spent subsequent months in the hospital, was also behind on her Bank of America mortgage.
The bank had been pursuing foreclosure, but managed to work out a repayment plan with the borrower, though it didn’t seem to come quickly enough.
By the time Morra arrived home from the holiday, the locks on her doors had been changed; it took another three days for her to make sense of the ordeal and gain access to the home, only to find that all the utilities were also shut off.
A Bank of America spokesman took responsibility for the changed locks, and said it would pay any costs associated with the mix-up.
Morra called the incident a “nightmare that didn’t have to happen.”
Bank of America issued a press release today, noting that it has provided more than 600,000 loan modifications since January 2008.
The company has also expanded its default management staffing to 13,000, though it’s unclear if that’s enough considering its hefty loan servicing portfolio.
Bank of America has been one of the weaker players under the Home Affordable Modification Program (HAMP), despite being the top mortgage lender as of the end of the third quarter.























